Fired Without Cause Lawyer: 4 Signs It Was Illegal

Employers rarely admit to breaking the law. They won’t tell you they’re firing you because of your age, your pregnancy, or because you reported harassment. Instead, they might say your position is being eliminated or simply state they are firing you without cause. This is where you need to become a detective in your own case. The timing of your termination, sudden negative performance reviews, or being excluded from important meetings can all be red flags that point to an illegal motive. This guide will walk you through the common signs of a wrongful termination and explain how a fired without cause lawyer uses this evidence to build a strong case on your behalf.

Key Takeaways

What Does “Fired Without Cause” Really Mean?

Losing your job is jarring, and it’s even more confusing when your employer gives a vague reason, or no reason at all. You might hear the term “fired without cause” and wonder if it’s legal. While it often is, there are critical exceptions you need to know about. Understanding the difference between an unfair firing and an illegal one is the first step to protecting your rights.

Understanding California’s “At-Will” Employment Rule

California is an “at-will” employment state. This means that, in most cases, your employer can end your employment at any time, for nearly any reason, or for no reason at all. They don’t need to prove you did something wrong. They can fire you because they don’t like your personality or want to hire their cousin instead. It feels unfair, but this rule isn’t a free pass for illegal behavior. California provides many protections for employees under its employment law framework, creating important limits on an employer’s power.

Fired Without Cause vs. Wrongful Termination

It’s important to distinguish between being “fired without cause” and a wrongful termination. While they feel the same, legally they are very different. Being fired without cause means your employer didn’t need a specific reason, which is generally allowed. A wrongful termination, however, happens when the real reason for your firing violates the law. For example, if your boss says it’s due to “restructuring,” but the actual reason is that you recently announced your pregnancy, that termination is illegal. The key isn’t the reason they gave; it’s the illegal motive they’re hiding.

Common Myths About At-Will Employment

A common myth is that “at-will” gives employers total power. This isn’t true. Your employer cannot fire you for reasons that violate public policy or specific laws. Federal and state laws create a safety net of protected classes and activities. For instance, it is illegal to fire you based on your race, gender, age, or disability. It’s also illegal for them to fire you as punishment for reporting illegal activity. If you suspect your “no cause” firing was actually a cover for illegal retaliation, you may have a strong case for wrongful termination.

When Is a “No Cause” Firing Actually Illegal?

While California’s “at-will” rule gives employers a lot of freedom, it isn’t a free pass to fire someone for any reason. Federal and state laws create important exceptions that protect employees from being fired for illegal reasons. If your employer says they are letting you go for “no cause” or for a vague reason that doesn’t add up, it could be a cover for something unlawful. Understanding these exceptions is the first step in figuring out if you have a case for wrongful termination.

Was Your Firing Discriminatory?

Your employer cannot fire you because of who you are. Federal and California laws protect employees from discrimination based on protected characteristics like your race, gender, religion, age, disability, or sexual orientation. If you believe your termination was motivated by prejudice, it is considered wrongful termination, even if your employer gives a different reason or no reason at all. For example, if you were the only person of color on your team and were let go during a “restructuring” while your white colleagues kept their jobs, that could be a sign of discrimination. Proving this often requires looking at patterns of behavior and how others were treated.

Was It Retaliation in Disguise?

Did you recently report harassment, ask for a reasonable accommodation for a disability, or take protected family leave? If you were fired shortly after doing something the law protects, your termination might be illegal retaliation. Employers are not allowed to punish employees for exercising their legal rights. For instance, if you complained to HR about unpaid overtime and were fired a week later for “not being a team player,” the timing is highly suspicious. The “no cause” reason could simply be a pretext, or a false reason, to hide the fact that they were retaliating against you for speaking up.

Were You Fired for Being a Whistleblower?

Being a whistleblower means you reported illegal, fraudulent, or unsafe activities happening at your company. If you were fired for reporting these violations, either internally or to an outside agency, you may have legal protection. For example, if you work in healthcare and reported patient safety violations to a regulatory board, your employer cannot fire you for it. Whistleblower protections are in place to encourage people to report wrongdoing without fear of losing their job. A sudden termination after you’ve raised serious concerns is a major red flag that your firing was unlawful.

Did Your Employer Break a Contract?

While many jobs are “at-will,” some employees have an employment contract that specifies the terms of their employment, including when and how they can be fired. This can be a formal, written document or even an implied contract based on promises made in an employee handbook or other company communications. If your contract states you can only be terminated for specific reasons (like misconduct or poor performance) and your employer fires you without meeting those conditions, you may have a claim for breach of contract. This is a key exception to the at-will rule that can support a wrongful termination case.

Public Policy Violations

Your employer cannot fire you for reasons that go against fundamental public policy. This is a broad but powerful protection. For example, you cannot be legally fired for refusing your boss’s order to commit a crime, like lying to investors or creating false safety reports. You also can’t be fired for exercising a legal right, such as filing a workers’ compensation claim after an injury or serving on a jury. When a termination punishes an employee for upholding the law or performing a civic duty, it undermines public policy and can be challenged as a wrongful termination under California employment law.

Red Flags That Your Firing Was Illegal

Losing a job is unsettling, but it can be even more confusing when the reason isn’t clear. While California is an “at-will” employment state, meaning an employer can fire you for almost any reason, that reason cannot be an illegal one. Unlawful terminations are rarely straightforward. An employer isn’t likely to admit they fired you for a discriminatory reason or as an act of retaliation. Instead, they often try to create a different, more legitimate-sounding narrative.

This is where learning to spot the red flags becomes so important. These warning signs are patterns of behavior that suggest your firing may have been motivated by something illegal. They can be subtle shifts in how you’re treated or sudden, drastic changes to your work environment. Understanding these signs can help you recognize when a seemingly “no cause” firing is actually a case of wrongful termination. Paying attention to these details can be the first step in protecting your rights.

Infographic titled 'Wrongful Termination: Know When No Cause Is Illegal' with five sections covering California at-will employment limits, four red flags of illegal firing, a 72-hour evidence checklist, five categories of legally protected termination claims, and a four-stage breakdown of the wrongful termination legal process, concluding with a call to action urging employees to document evidence and consult a lawyer before signing severance agreements.

Sudden, Unexplained Negative Reviews

You’ve had years of positive feedback and a great track record. Then, shortly after you reported an issue or requested leave, you’re suddenly hit with a negative performance review. This isn’t a coincidence; it’s a classic tactic. An employer may try to build a “paper trail” of poor performance to justify a firing they already planned for an illegal reason. If your work quality hasn’t changed but the feedback has, especially after you’ve engaged in a protected activity like complaining about harassment, it’s a major red flag. This sudden criticism is often not about your performance at all, but about creating a pretext for letting you go.

Being Excluded or Sidelined at Work

Have you been left off key email threads, disinvited from meetings you always attended, or had important projects reassigned without a clear explanation? This professional isolation is a common strategy to sideline an employee before firing them. The goal is to make your position seem less critical to the company’s operations, making it easier to eliminate your role under the guise of “restructuring” or “downsizing.” This behavior can make your job impossible to perform and create a hostile work environment. It’s a way for an employer to push you out indirectly while preparing to make your termination look like a simple business decision.

Facing Pressure to Resign

Sometimes, an employer will try to get you to quit to avoid the legal risks of firing you. Your manager might start making comments that you seem unhappy, that the role isn’t a good fit anymore, or that you’d be better off somewhere else. This can escalate into a situation where your work life is made so miserable that you feel you have no choice but to resign. This is known as constructive discharge. If you’re being pressured to quit and then see your job posted online shortly after you leave, it’s a strong sign that the company wanted you gone for a specific, and potentially illegal, reason. They wanted the position, just not with you in it.

Seeing Policy Changes That Target You

While companies can update their policies, these changes should apply fairly to all employees. A red flag appears when a new rule seems conveniently tailored to create a problem specifically for you. For instance, imagine you have an approved accommodation for a flexible schedule due to family obligations. Suddenly, your company implements a strict, mandatory start time that you can’t meet. This isn’t just an inconvenient policy change; it could be a subtle attempt to force you out. This tactic is often used to mask retaliation or discrimination by creating a new rule you’re bound to break, giving the employer a seemingly valid reason for your termination.

Your Legal Protections as a California Employee

Even though California is an “at-will” employment state, that doesn’t give your employer a free pass to fire you for any reason. A powerful network of federal and state laws creates a safety net to protect you from illegal termination. Understanding these protections is the first step toward recognizing when your rights have been violated. These laws ensure that firings aren’t based on discrimination, retaliation, or other unlawful motives. If you suspect your “no cause” firing was actually a cover for something illegal, knowing your rights can help you decide what to do next.

Your Rights Under Federal Law

Think of federal laws as the foundation of your workplace rights. Several key statutes protect employees across the country from wrongful termination. The Civil Rights Act of 1964, for example, makes it illegal for an employer to fire you based on your race, color, religion, sex, or national origin. The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) adds to this by protecting qualified individuals with disabilities from discrimination. Furthermore, the Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA) gives eligible employees the right to take job-protected leave for specific family and medical reasons. These federal laws establish a baseline of protection that employers everywhere must follow.

California’s Strong Employee Protections

California takes employee rights a step further with some of the strongest protections in the nation. The main law here is the California Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA), which offers broader protection than its federal counterparts. FEHA prohibits discrimination and harassment based on a longer list of protected categories, including marital status, gender identity, and sexual orientation. Additionally, California’s Labor Code is very clear about protecting employees from retaliation. This means your employer cannot legally punish you for asserting your rights, like reporting harassment or participating in a workplace investigation. These state-specific laws provide an extra layer of security for California workers.

Family and Medical Leave Rights

If you need to take time off for your health or to care for a loved one, California law has your back. The California Family Rights Act (CFRA) works alongside the federal FMLA to provide robust leave rights. Under CFRA, eligible employees can take up to 12 weeks of unpaid, job-protected leave. This can be for bonding with a new child, caring for a family member with a serious health condition, or managing your own serious illness. Crucially, your employer cannot fire you or take any adverse action against you for exercising your right to family and medical leave.

Protection Against Wage and Hour Retaliation

You have the right to be paid fairly for your work, and you also have the right to speak up if you aren’t. California law strictly prohibits employers from retaliating against you for asserting your wage and hour rights. This means you cannot be fired, demoted, or punished for actions like filing a claim for unpaid overtime, reporting missed meal and rest breaks, or questioning minimum wage violations. This protection ensures you can stand up for your right to proper pay without fearing for your job. If you face any negative action after raising a wage issue, it could be a case of illegal retaliation.

What to Do Immediately After Being Fired

Being fired is a jarring experience, even if you saw it coming. Your mind is likely racing, and it’s easy to feel overwhelmed and powerless. But the moments and days right after your termination are critical. Taking a few specific, intentional steps can help you protect your rights and preserve your options if you believe your firing was illegal. Think of this as your immediate action plan. It’s not about getting revenge; it’s about ensuring you have what you need to move forward, whether that means filing a claim or simply closing this chapter with peace of mind. Before you do anything else, take a deep breath and focus on these four steps. They can make all the difference in what happens next.

Document Everything

Your memory is a powerful tool, but it’s not perfect, especially when you’re under stress. Start a journal or a digital file and write down everything you can remember about your termination. What day and time did it happen? Who was in the room? What reason, if any, were you given for being let go? Write down the conversation as you remember it, word for word. Also, make notes of any relevant events leading up to the firing. This detailed timeline is one of the most valuable pieces of information you can have if you decide to pursue a wrongful termination claim.

Gather Your Evidence

While you still have access, gather any documents that could be relevant to your employment and termination. This isn’t the time to be shy. Collect copies of your employment contract, the company handbook, your performance reviews (especially positive ones), and any emails or messages that feel important. This could include praise from your manager, communications about a medical condition, or complaints you made about workplace issues. Save these files to a personal device or cloud storage account, not your work computer. This evidence provides a factual backbone for your story and can be essential in proving your case.

Know Your Filing Deadlines

The law sets strict time limits, called statutes of limitations, for filing legal claims. If you miss this window, you could lose your right to take action forever, no matter how strong your case is. These deadlines vary depending on the nature of your claim. For example, the timeline for filing a discrimination complaint is different from the one for a wage and hour dispute. It’s crucial to understand which deadlines apply to your situation. Acting quickly ensures that you keep all your legal options open while you figure out your next steps.

Avoid These Common Case-Killing Mistakes

First, do not sign anything without having a lawyer review it. Employers often offer a severance package in exchange for you signing a release, which is a legal document that waives your right to sue them for any reason. It might be tempting to take the money, but you could be signing away a much more valuable claim. Second, don’t assume you have to fight this alone. Employers often create a pretext, or a false reason, for an illegal firing to protect themselves. An experienced employment law attorney can help you see through these tactics and understand the true strength of your case.

How a Wrongful Termination Lawyer Can Help

Figuring out what to do after an unfair firing can feel overwhelming, but you don’t have to face it alone. While it’s technically possible to handle a claim yourself, the legal system is complex and has strict deadlines. Bringing in a professional who lives and breathes this work can make all the difference. A wrongful termination lawyer acts as your advocate, guide, and fighter, handling the legal heavy lifting so you can focus on your next steps. They understand the tactics employers use and know how to build a strong case on your behalf.

Evaluate Your Case

The first thing an experienced lawyer will do is sit down with you to hear your story. They will carefully review the details of your employment and termination to determine if your firing was illegal. This initial case evaluation is critical. An attorney can spot violations you might not recognize, connect the dots between your employer’s actions and the law, and give you an honest assessment of your options. They help you understand your rights and what kind of evidence is needed to prove a wrongful termination claim, giving you a clear path forward from day one.

File Official Complaints for You

If you have a valid claim, there’s a specific legal process you must follow. This often involves filing a formal complaint with a government agency like the federal Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) or California’s Civil Rights Department (CRD) before you can even file a lawsuit. These agencies have strict procedures and deadlines that can be confusing. Your lawyer will handle all of this for you. They will draft the complaint, gather the necessary documents, and ensure everything is filed correctly and on time, preventing simple mistakes that could jeopardize your case for retaliation or discrimination.

Negotiate a Settlement or Go to Trial

Most employment disputes are resolved through a settlement, not a dramatic courtroom trial. An experienced lawyer is also a skilled negotiator who can advocate for a fair settlement on your behalf. This could include compensation for lost wages (back pay), future lost wages, emotional distress, and sometimes even getting your job back. If your former employer is unwilling to offer a reasonable settlement for the discrimination you faced, your attorney will be prepared to take your case to court. Having a lawyer who is ready and willing to go to trial often gives you more leverage during negotiations.

How Much Does a Wrongful Termination Lawyer Cost?

If you’ve been illegally fired, the thought of paying for a lawyer can feel overwhelming, especially when you’ve just lost your income. It’s a valid concern, and it’s one that keeps too many people from seeking the justice they deserve. But here’s something you should know: you don’t need a lot of money saved up to hire an excellent employment lawyer. Most reputable plaintiff’s employment law firms, including Bluestone Law, handle these cases on what’s called a contingency fee basis.

This arrangement is specifically designed to help people in your exact situation. In simple terms, it means your lawyer only gets paid if they win your case, either through a settlement or a court verdict. Their payment is a pre-agreed percentage of the money they recover for you. This model removes the financial barrier to legal representation and ensures your lawyer is fully invested in getting you the best possible outcome. When you’re looking for a wrongful termination attorney in California, understanding this fee structure is key. It aligns your goals with your lawyer’s goals: to win your case and secure fair compensation for the harm you’ve suffered. While the contingency fee covers your attorney’s payment, it’s also helpful to know about other potential costs that can come up during a lawsuit, which we’ll break down next.

How Contingency Fees Work

A contingency fee is essentially a “no win, no fee” promise. If your lawyer doesn’t secure a settlement or win a judgment for you, you owe them nothing for their time and effort. If they are successful, their fee is a percentage of your total recovery, which typically ranges from 25% to 40%. This percentage is agreed upon in writing before any work begins, so there are no surprises. This model provides access to the legal system for everyone, not just those who can afford to pay a lawyer’s hourly rate. It also means the law firm takes on the financial risk of your case, which is a strong signal that they believe in its merits and are committed to fighting for you.

Understanding Other Potential Costs

While the contingency fee covers your lawyer’s legal services, it’s important to distinguish between “fees” and “costs.” Every lawsuit involves certain out-of-pocket expenses, known as case costs. These can include court filing fees, the cost of serving legal documents, court reporter fees for depositions, and fees for expert witnesses if they are needed. You should always ask a potential lawyer how these costs are handled. Many firms, like our firm, will advance these costs on your behalf and then deduct them from your settlement at the end of the case. This means you still pay nothing upfront. Your fee agreement should clearly outline all of this, so be sure to review it carefully and ask questions before you sign.

What to Expect from the Legal Process

The legal system can feel intimidating, but understanding the road ahead can make it much more manageable. While every case is unique, most wrongful termination claims follow a similar path. Knowing these steps helps you prepare for what’s next and feel more in control of your situation. From the first conversation with an attorney to the final resolution, here’s a breakdown of what you can generally expect as you pursue your claim.

The Initial Consultation and Case Review

Your first step is to talk with an experienced employment lawyer. If you think you were fired unfairly, it’s best to contact a lawyer as soon as possible. An attorney can help you understand your rights, figure out what evidence you need, and make sure you don’t miss any strict legal deadlines. During this initial consultation, you’ll share the details of your situation, and the lawyer will evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of your potential case. This meeting is completely confidential and is your opportunity to get clear, professional advice on whether you have a valid claim and what your next steps should be.

Filing a Claim or Lawsuit

If your lawyer believes you have a strong case, the next step is to take formal action. For many types of illegal termination, especially those involving discrimination, you must first file a claim with a government agency like the federal Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) or California’s Civil Rights Department (CRD). This is a required step before you can file a lawsuit in court. Your attorney will handle preparing and filing these documents for you, making sure all the necessary information is included and that everything is submitted on time. Once this administrative process is complete, your lawyer can then proceed with filing a lawsuit against your former employer.

The Discovery and Negotiation Stage

This is the phase where both sides gather evidence. It’s called “discovery,” and it involves exchanging documents, asking written questions (interrogatories), and conducting interviews under oath (depositions). Proving wrongful termination can be challenging because employers often create a different story to justify their actions. A skilled wrongful termination attorney can use the discovery process to uncover the truth and find evidence that supports your claim. As evidence comes to light, your lawyer may begin negotiations with your former employer to see if a fair settlement can be reached without going to court.

Reaching a Resolution: Settlement vs. Trial

Most employment cases are resolved through a settlement, which is a confidential agreement between you and your former employer. Your lawyer will negotiate on your behalf to get you the best possible outcome. If a fair agreement can’t be reached, your case may proceed to trial, where a judge or jury will decide the outcome. If you win a wrongful termination case, you could be awarded damages like back pay for lost wages, compensation for emotional distress, and sometimes even get your job back. The goal is always to secure the best resolution for you, whether that happens through a strong settlement or a successful trial.

How to Choose the Right Lawyer for Your Case

Finding the right legal partner is one of the most important steps you will take. After being fired, you might feel overwhelmed, angry, and unsure of who to trust. It’s tempting to go with the first lawyer you find, but taking the time to choose the right one can make all the difference in your case. Your former employer has a legal team on their side, and you deserve an expert advocate who is fully committed to fighting for you. Think of this as building your personal support team; you want the most qualified and dedicated player in your corner.

You need someone who sees you as a person, not just a case file. This journey requires a partnership built on trust and clear communication. The right lawyer will not only provide sound legal advice but also act as your guide through the legal system, explaining each step and managing your expectations along the way. They will be your strategist and your champion, working to level the playing field against a company that has far more resources. Choosing carefully at this stage gives you the best chance at securing the justice you deserve.

Find a Specialist in Employment Law

Employment law is a complex and constantly changing field. Because of this, you should look for a lawyer who specializes exclusively in this area. A general practice attorney might handle a divorce one day and a real estate dispute the next; they simply don’t have the deep knowledge required to effectively handle a wrongful termination case. Employers and their insurance companies have experienced lawyers whose entire job is to defend against employee claims. You need to level the playing field with an expert of your own.

A specialist in employment law lives and breathes these issues. They understand the specific tactics employers use, know the judges and opposing attorneys, and are up-to-date on the strict deadlines and procedures that can make or break a case. They can accurately assess the strength of your claim and build the strongest possible argument on your behalf.

Review Their Track Record

When you’re vetting a potential lawyer, their past performance is a strong indicator of their ability to handle your case. Look for a firm that is transparent about its history of success. Do they have a proven track record of securing favorable outcomes for employees? While every case is unique and past results don’t guarantee a future outcome, a history of substantial settlements and verdicts shows that the firm has the experience and resources to take on powerful employers.

Look for client testimonials and case results on their website. This will give you a sense of their reputation and their dedicated focus on advocating for employees. A firm with a strong track record isn’t afraid to go to trial if a fair settlement can’t be reached. This willingness to fight sends a powerful message to your former employer and can lead to a better resolution for you.

Key Questions to Ask During Your Consultation

Your initial consultation is more than just a chance to tell your story; it’s a two-way interview. This is your opportunity to determine if a lawyer is the right fit for you and your case. Come prepared with any evidence you have, like emails, performance reviews, or contact information for witnesses. Being organized will help the attorney get a clear picture of your situation.

Here are some key questions to ask:

How Bluestone Law Can Help

Figuring out if your firing was illegal and what to do next can feel overwhelming, especially when you’re already dealing with the stress of losing your job. You don’t have to face your former employer alone. At Bluestone Law, we focus exclusively on protecting employees’ rights, and we’re here to guide you through every step of the process.

Evaluate Your Case

The first thing we’ll do is sit down with you to understand the full story. We’ll help you determine if your termination violates California law. This involves a careful review of your employment history, performance reviews, emails, and any other evidence you have. Even if your employer didn’t give a reason for letting you go, we can often uncover signs of illegal motives, like discrimination. Our goal is to give you a clear and honest assessment of your situation and explain your legal options for pursuing a wrongful termination claim.

File Official Complaints for You

If we determine you have a strong case, we’ll handle all the complicated legal filings for you. This often starts with filing a formal complaint with the appropriate state or federal agency, like California’s Civil Rights Department (CRD). These agencies have strict deadlines and procedural rules that can be tricky to manage on your own. We take care of the paperwork and communications so you can focus on your next steps. By managing these critical filings, we ensure your rights are preserved and your case against illegal retaliation at work or other unlawful actions is properly initiated.

Negotiate a Settlement or Go to Trial

Our team will advocate for you to get the justice you deserve. In many cases, this means negotiating a fair settlement with your former employer that compensates you for lost wages, emotional distress, and other damages. We are skilled negotiators who will fight for the best possible outcome without you ever having to step into a courtroom. However, if your employer refuses to offer a fair settlement, we are fully prepared to take your case to trial. As experienced litigators, the team at Our Firm is ready to powerfully represent your interests in court.

Related Articles

Frequently Asked Questions

My boss didn’t give a reason for firing me. Is that legal? Yes, in most cases, it is legal. California is an “at-will” employment state, which means your employer can fire you at any time without providing a specific reason. However, this rule has limits. The real, unstated reason for your termination cannot be an illegal one, such as discrimination based on your race or retaliation for reporting harassment.

What’s the difference between being fired unfairly and being fired illegally? An unfair firing might feel wrong, but it’s not against the law. For example, getting fired because your boss simply doesn’t like your personality is unfair, but it’s legal. An illegal firing, or wrongful termination, happens when the reason for your termination violates a specific law. This includes being fired because of your age, gender, or disability, or as punishment for exercising a legal right, like taking family leave.

I was offered a severance package. Should I sign it? You should not sign anything without having it reviewed by an employment lawyer. Most severance agreements require you to sign a release, which means you give up your right to sue your former employer for any reason, including wrongful termination. While the money can be tempting, you might be signing away a much more valuable legal claim.

How can I prove my firing was illegal if my boss made up a different reason? This is a common concern, as employers rarely admit to breaking the law. An experienced lawyer helps by gathering evidence to show that the reason you were given was just a pretext, or a false excuse. This evidence can include the timing of your firing, your history of positive performance reviews, emails, and testimony from other employees. The goal is to build a case that reveals the employer’s true, illegal motive.

I just lost my income. How can I possibly afford a lawyer? Most reputable employment law firms, including ours, handle wrongful termination cases on a contingency fee basis. This means you pay nothing upfront for legal services. The lawyer’s fee is a percentage of the money they recover for you through a settlement or court verdict. If you don’t win your case, you don’t owe any attorney’s fees. This model ensures that everyone has access to justice, regardless of their financial situation.

Think you were wrongfully terminated?

Get a free, confidential case evaluation from our experienced employment law attorneys.

Request Your Free Consultation
← Previous The 4 Elements of a Prima Facie Age Discrimination Claim