Receiving a severance package can feel like a whirlwind of emotions and paperwork. In the rush to figure out your next steps, you might be tempted to sign the agreement quickly just to get it over with. This is one of the biggest mistakes you can make. That document is a legal contract written by your employer’s lawyers to protect the company, not you. It almost always requires you to sign away your right to sue for issues like wrongful termination. This guide will walk you through the essentials of how to counter offer a severance package, giving you the tools to secure a better deal.
Key Takeaways
- Everything Is Negotiable: Your employer’s first offer is a starting point, not a final decision. You can ask for more than just a higher payment, including extended health insurance, payouts for unused PTO, and professional outplacement services.
- Justify Your Ask with Facts: A strong counteroffer is based on your professional value, not personal need. Use your performance reviews, key accomplishments, and industry standards to build a logical case for why you deserve a better package.
- Know What Rights You’re Waiving: A severance agreement is a legal contract that prevents you from suing the company in the future. If you suspect your termination was illegal or the terms seem unfair, have an employment lawyer review the document before you sign anything.
What Is a Severance Package?
When you part ways with an employer, they might offer you a severance package. Think of it as a final exchange. It typically includes two parts: severance pay (the money and benefits you receive) and a severance agreement (the legal document you sign to get it). This agreement is the most critical piece to understand. By signing it, you are usually promising not to sue the company for any reason related to your employment, such as wrongful termination or discrimination. You might also agree to keep company information confidential or not to say anything negative about them publicly.
It’s a formal contract that ends your employment relationship. While the extra pay and benefits can provide a much-needed cushion, it’s important to know exactly what rights you’re giving up in return. The company offers a package to protect itself from future legal action and to ensure a smooth transition. For you, it’s a chance to secure financial stability while you look for your next opportunity. Before you sign anything, take the time to read every line and understand what it means for your future.
What to Look for in Your Severance Offer
Many people assume a severance offer is a take-it-or-leave-it deal, but that’s rarely the case. These packages are almost always negotiable. Your first step is to carefully review the terms. Look for key clauses like the “General Release of Claims,” which is the legal promise not to sue. Also, pay attention to any confidentiality or non-disparagement agreements that restrict what you can say about the company after you leave. These clauses can have long-term effects on your career, so you need to know what you’re agreeing to.
Beyond the legal language, check the practical benefits. Does the package include continued health insurance? Your employer might cover your premiums for a few months, or the agreement might simply outline your option to continue coverage through COBRA, which you would pay for yourself. Other negotiable items can include outplacement services to help you find a new job or a positive letter of reference. Understanding every component of the offer is the first step toward deciding if you should ask for more.
What Your Employer Is Required to Offer
Here’s a crucial point many people don’t realize: in most cases, employers are not legally required to offer severance pay. There is no federal or California law that mandates it for every employee who is laid off or terminated. So, if you’ve received an offer, it’s because the company has chosen to provide one. They might do this to honor a pre-existing employment contract, maintain a positive reputation, or, most commonly, to prevent potential legal claims from you down the road.
Because it’s not a legal requirement, the company has a strong incentive—your signature on that release of claims—to offer a package. This is where your leverage comes from. It’s also helpful to know that receiving severance pay typically doesn’t disqualify you from collecting unemployment benefits, though it can depend on the specifics of the company’s plan. The fact that severance is optional for employers makes it even more important to review any offer carefully with a professional who understands employment law.
Should You Negotiate Your Severance Package?
When your employer hands you a severance package, it’s easy to feel like the offer is set in stone. But here’s something many people don’t realize: severance agreements are often negotiable. Think of the initial offer as a starting point for a conversation, not the final word. While some companies have standard policies, many decisions are made on a case-by-case basis, especially for employees with a long history at the company or those in senior roles.
Losing a job is stressful enough without feeling like you’re leaving money or benefits on the table. Taking the time to review your package and consider a counteroffer is a crucial step in protecting your financial future. It’s about ensuring the agreement fairly reflects your contributions and provides a stable bridge to your next opportunity. If you were let go under questionable circumstances, such as a potential wrongful termination, you may have even more leverage than you think. The key is to understand your position and what you can reasonably ask for.
Signs You Have Room to Negotiate
Not sure if your offer has any wiggle room? Certain situations can give you a stronger negotiating position. If you were part of a large layoff, forced to resign, or your departure is tied to major company changes, your employer might be more flexible. Your value to the company is also a powerful factor. A long tenure, a track record of strong performance, and significant contributions to the business all serve as excellent points of leverage. An employer may also be more willing to negotiate if they want to avoid any risk of a lawsuit, especially if there are circumstances that could point to discrimination or other illegal actions.
Red Flags in Your Initial Offer
As you review your severance agreement, keep an eye out for a few red flags. A major one is feeling rushed or pressured to sign the document immediately. This can be a tactic to get you to sign away important legal rights without fully understanding what you’re agreeing to. Be wary of overly restrictive clauses, like a non-compete agreement that could limit your ability to find a new job in your field. If the agreement asks you to waive all potential legal claims against the company, it’s essential to pause and consider what you might be giving up. These are all significant reasons to push back and negotiate for better terms.
What Can You Negotiate in a Severance Package?
When your employer hands you a severance agreement, it’s easy to feel like the terms are set in stone. But here’s something many people don’t realize: the initial offer is usually just a starting point. A severance package is a contract, and like most contracts, it’s open to negotiation. Thinking beyond the initial dollar amount can help you secure a much better exit package that truly supports your transition to a new role.
Many components of a severance package are on the table for discussion. You can negotiate for more money, of course, but you can also ask for extended health benefits, a payout for unused vacation time, and even professional outplacement services to help you land your next job. The key is to understand what’s possible and what’s most important for your specific situation. If you were let go under circumstances that could point to wrongful termination, you may have even more leverage. Approaching the conversation with a clear, well-researched strategy is the best way to protect your interests and leave on the best possible terms.
More Severance Pay
The most obvious part of the package to negotiate is the payment itself. Many companies have a standard formula, often offering one to two weeks of pay for every year you worked there. However, this is more of a guideline than a strict rule. If you were a key contributor, have been with the company for a long time, or are leaving under complicated circumstances, you have a strong case for asking for more.
Don’t assume the first number they give you is final. Companies often expect a counteroffer and may have built some wiggle room into their initial proposal. Think about your tenure, your performance, and the impact of your departure on the company. Frame your request around these contributions to justify why a more generous severance payment is fair.
Longer Health Insurance Coverage
Losing your job often means losing your health insurance, which can be a major source of stress. While you’re generally entitled to continue your coverage through COBRA for up to 18 months, you’re also responsible for paying the full premium, which can be incredibly expensive. This is a huge opportunity for negotiation.
Instead of just accepting the standard COBRA offer, you can ask your employer to pay for your health insurance premiums for a few months as part of your severance. This can provide a critical financial cushion while you search for a new job with benefits. Given the high cost of healthcare, having your former employer cover your premiums for an extended period can be just as valuable, if not more so, than a higher cash payout.
Other Perks and Benefits
A strong severance package goes beyond cash and health insurance. Think about other benefits that could make your transition smoother. For example, you can and should ask to be paid out for any unused vacation, sick days, or paid time off (PTO) you’ve accrued. This is money you’ve already earned, and you’re entitled to it.
You can also negotiate for non-monetary benefits. Ask for professional outplacement services, which can include resume writing help, interview coaching, and networking support. Another point of negotiation could be your official termination date. Pushing it back by a few weeks could allow you to vest in a retirement plan or qualify for another month of benefits. These perks can add significant value to your overall package.
How to Calculate a Fair Severance Package
Before you can ask for more, you need a clear idea of what a fair package looks like for someone in your position. Calculating this number helps you move from feeling like the offer is too low to being able to explain why it is. This isn’t about what you feel you deserve; it’s about building a logical case based on standard practices and your specific value to the company. A well-reasoned calculation is the foundation of a strong counteroffer and shows your employer that you’ve done your homework.
Consider Industry Standards
A good starting point is to look at what’s common in your field. Many companies follow an unwritten rule of offering one to two weeks of pay for every year you’ve worked for them. Some are more generous, offering up to three weeks per year of service. Check your employee handbook first, as your company might have a specific formula written down. If they do, that’s your baseline. If your initial offer doesn’t even meet your company’s stated policy, you have a very clear and direct point for negotiation. Understanding these standards helps you gauge whether your offer is reasonable or falls short of what you should expect.
Factor in Your Contributions
Next, think about your unique impact on the company. A standard formula doesn’t account for the fact that you were a top performer or played a key role in major projects. Your negotiation should be based on objective business reasons, not personal circumstances. Make a list of your accomplishments, positive performance reviews, and any specific contributions that generated revenue or saved the company money. Were you a long-serving employee who showed incredible loyalty? This is your chance to remind them of the value you brought to the table. If you were laid off as part of a wrongful termination, your leverage is even greater.
How to Prepare Your Counteroffer
Walking into a negotiation unprepared is like trying to build furniture without the instructions. You might get it done, but the result probably won’t be what you hoped for. A successful severance negotiation starts long before you ever speak with HR. It begins with careful preparation, thoughtful strategy, and a clear understanding of what you’re asking for and why you deserve it. By taking the time to build a strong case, you shift the conversation from an emotional plea to a business discussion based on your value and contributions.
This preparation involves more than just deciding on a number. You need to gather concrete evidence of your performance, understand the legal ground you stand on by reviewing your employment agreement, and give yourself the space to think clearly without pressure. It’s also about looking inward to define what a successful outcome truly means for you and your family. Is it more cash in hand, a longer healthcare bridge, or professional support for your next chapter? Getting organized around these key areas will give you the confidence and clarity you need to present a compelling counteroffer.
Gather Your Documentation
Before you can ask for more, you need to prove why you’re worth it. Your leverage in a negotiation comes from demonstrating the value you brought to the company. Start by compiling a file of your accomplishments. This includes positive performance reviews, emails from managers or clients praising your work, and any awards or recognitions you received. If your role was tied to metrics, gather data on your successes, like sales figures you hit or projects you completed on time and under budget. You can ask for more by referencing your specific contributions and successes. This isn’t about being boastful; it’s about presenting a fact-based case for why a more generous package is a fair acknowledgment of your impact.
Review Your Employment Contract
Your original employment contract or offer letter is your starting point. This document may contain a clause that outlines the company’s severance policy or other post-employment obligations. Pull it out and read it carefully. Look for any language that specifies how much severance pay you are entitled to, if any. Understanding these initial terms is crucial because it establishes a baseline. If your employer’s offer meets the contractual minimum, you know that any negotiation is for benefits above and beyond what they are legally required to provide. If you believe your termination was unlawful, understanding your contract is the first step in exploring a potential wrongful termination claim.
Don’t Rush Your Review
Employers often present severance agreements with a deadline, hoping you’ll sign quickly without much thought. Don’t fall into this trap. You have the right to take time to review the offer, and it’s wise to use it. Signing too fast can mean you give up important legal rights. A standard severance agreement includes a “release of claims,” which means you forfeit your right to sue the company for any reason related to your employment, including issues like workplace retaliation or discrimination. Federal law gives employees over 40 at least 21 days to consider an age discrimination waiver, which is a good benchmark for anyone. Take the time to read every line and understand exactly what you are agreeing to.
Define Your Must-Haves
A successful negotiation requires a clear goal. Before you draft a counteroffer, decide what is most important to you. Is your top priority maximizing your severance pay to cover expenses while you search for a new job? Or is extending your health insurance coverage the most critical need for your family? Other negotiable benefits can include outplacement services to help with your job search, a positive letter of recommendation, or allowing you to keep company property like a laptop. Make a list of your priorities, separating your “must-haves” from your “nice-to-haves.” This focus will help you communicate your needs clearly and make strategic concessions if necessary.
How to Present Your Counteroffer
Once you’ve done your homework and know what you’re asking for, it’s time to have the conversation. How you approach this discussion is just as important as what you’re requesting. This isn’t about being confrontational; it’s a business negotiation, and your goal is to reach a fair agreement that helps you move forward. A successful negotiation hinges on a few key elements: timing your conversation correctly, framing your requests in a positive light, and communicating with professionalism and clarity.
Presenting a thoughtful counteroffer shows that you understand your value and are serious about reaching a mutually beneficial resolution. It’s also a critical step if you believe your termination was handled improperly. If you suspect your layoff was a form of retaliation or discrimination, the terms of your severance become even more significant. By approaching the negotiation strategically, you can protect your interests and secure the resources you need for your transition. The following steps will help you present your case effectively and confidently.
Time Your Conversation Right
When you receive a severance offer, your first instinct might be to react immediately, but the best thing you can do is pause. Don’t sign anything right away. Most employers expect you to take some time to review the document—often a week or more. Use this period to fully understand the terms, calculate what you believe is fair, and prepare your counteroffer.
Rushing this process can be a costly mistake. Severance agreements almost always require you to waive your right to pursue legal action against the company for issues like wrongful termination. By taking your time, you give yourself the space to think clearly and consult with an attorney if needed. This shows your former employer that you are being thoughtful and deliberate, which sets a professional tone for the negotiation.
Frame Your Requests as a Win-Win
Instead of presenting your counteroffer as a list of demands, frame it as a collaborative solution. Think about what your employer needs right now—likely a smooth transition and minimal disruption. You can use this to your advantage. Explain how your requests can also benefit the company. For example, you could offer to stay on for an extra week to finalize a project or create a detailed guide for your replacement in exchange for an additional week of severance pay.
This approach shifts the dynamic from adversarial to cooperative. You’re not just asking for more; you’re offering something of value in return. You could say something like, “I’m committed to ensuring a seamless handover. I’d be happy to provide additional transition support, and I’d like the severance package to reflect that extra contribution.” This makes your requests feel more reasonable and shows you’re focused on a positive outcome for everyone.
Communicate Clearly and Professionally
Whether you’re writing an email or speaking with HR, your communication should be polite, concise, and professional. Avoid emotional language or writing a long message detailing your grievances. Your goal is to negotiate the terms of your exit, not to rehash past issues. Stick to the facts and be direct about what you are asking for.
You can start the conversation with a simple and respectful request. For example: “Thank you for providing the severance agreement. After reviewing it, I’d like to discuss some adjustments to better reflect my contributions and help ensure a smooth transition.” Or, “I appreciate the offer. I was hoping the company would be open to a modest increase to help me through this period.” This tone keeps the conversation professional and focused on finding a solution, which is always the most effective way to negotiate.
Common Negotiation Mistakes to Avoid
When you’re negotiating a severance package, emotions can run high. It’s normal to feel frustrated, but letting those feelings guide your strategy can backfire. The key to a successful negotiation is to remain calm, professional, and strategic. Knowing what pitfalls to avoid is just as important as knowing which steps to take. A few common missteps can quickly derail your counteroffer, making your former employer less willing to cooperate. By approaching the conversation with a clear head, you can sidestep these errors and keep the focus on reaching a fair agreement.
Getting Too Personal
It’s easy to feel like your termination is a personal attack, but it’s crucial to keep your negotiation professional. Making demands or venting frustrations will likely put the HR representative on the defensive and shut down the conversation. Remember, this is a business transaction. Frame your requests politely and focus on the practical aspects of your transition. A simple, professional request is far more effective. For example, you could say, “Thank you for this offer. To help with my transition, would you be open to increasing the severance pay to [your requested amount]?” This keeps the tone collaborative.
Exaggerating Your Claims
Your strongest bargaining chip in a severance negotiation is often the potential legal claims you might have against the company. If you have a legitimate concern about wrongful termination, that gives you real leverage. However, it’s critical that you stick to the facts. Be careful not to invent or exaggerate claims to try and get a better deal. If you say something that isn’t true, you’ll lose all credibility, and your employer will be far less likely to negotiate. Your position is strongest when it’s built on a foundation of truth. Document the facts without embellishing them.
Rushing the Process
Your employer might present the severance agreement with a sense of urgency, encouraging you to sign it quickly. Don’t fall for it. This is a legally binding document, and you have the right to take your time to review it thoroughly. Signing too fast can mean you unknowingly give up important legal rights, like the ability to sue for a hostile work environment you may have endured. Most offers give you a specific period for review—often 21 days for employees over 40. Use this time to read every clause carefully. Rushing this critical step is one of the biggest mistakes you can make.
Do You Need a Lawyer to Negotiate Severance?
Let’s be direct: severance agreements are legal documents written by your employer’s lawyers to protect the company. While you aren’t legally required to have an attorney review it, going it alone can be a huge risk. Having an experienced employment lawyer on your side levels the playing field. They can help you understand the fine print, identify potential legal claims you might be giving up, and assess whether the offer is fair for your situation.
Negotiating a severance package is often more complex than just asking for more money. An attorney can help you see the full picture, including the value of non-monetary benefits and the long-term implications of what you’re signing. They bring a calm, objective perspective to an emotional situation and can handle the back-and-forth with HR or the company’s legal team. Think of it as bringing a professional to a professional negotiation. A lawyer can help you confidently protect your rights and ensure you aren’t leaving money or benefits on the table.
When to Call an Employment Lawyer
Certain situations are clear signals that you need legal advice. You should absolutely consult an employment lawyer if your severance agreement includes restrictive clauses like non-compete or non-solicitation agreements that could limit your future job prospects. It’s also critical to seek counsel if you believe your termination was connected to illegal activity. If you were laid off after reporting harassment or discrimination, or if you suspect your job loss was a form of retaliation, a lawyer can help you preserve your legal claims and negotiate a package that reflects the circumstances of your departure. Don’t sign away your rights without understanding their full value.
What a “Release of Claims” Really Means
Nearly every severance agreement contains a “General Release of Claims.” In simple terms, this is the section where you agree not to sue the company for any past issues in exchange for the severance package. This clause is incredibly broad and can cover everything from unpaid wages to wrongful termination. It’s essential to understand exactly what you are giving up. However, there are some rights you generally cannot waive, such as your right to file a worker’s compensation claim or report illegal activity as a whistleblower. An attorney can review this clause carefully to explain its impact and ensure it’s legally sound.
What to Expect After You Counteroffer
You’ve done the hard part: you’ve reviewed your severance agreement, assessed your needs, and submitted a thoughtful counteroffer. Now comes the waiting game. This phase can be nerve-wracking, but it helps to remember that this is a business negotiation. Your former employer has a budget and a process for handling these requests, and their response will be based on those factors, not on you personally.
After you present your counteroffer, your employer will likely review it with their HR and legal teams. Their response can take a few different forms. They might accept your proposal as is, reject it outright, or come back with a new offer that lands somewhere in the middle. Each of these outcomes is a real possibility, and being prepared for them will help you handle the final stages of the negotiation with confidence. The key is to remain professional and patient as you await their decision. Your goal is to reach a final agreement that feels fair and provides a stable bridge to your next opportunity.
How Your Employer Might Respond
Once you’ve sent your counteroffer, the ball is in your employer’s court. Most companies are accustomed to severance negotiations and will respond in one of three ways. In the best-case scenario, they accept your terms. If your request was reasonable and well-supported, this is a definite possibility. Alternatively, they might reject your counteroffer and hold firm on their original package. While disappointing, remember that the worst they can usually say is no. The third and most common outcome is that they’ll come back with a counter-counteroffer—a compromise between their initial proposal and your request. If they refuse to negotiate and you suspect your termination was unlawful, an attorney can help you understand your options for employment law claims.
Get the Final Agreement in Writing
No matter how amicable your negotiation feels, verbal promises are not enough. Once you and your employer have settled on the final terms, insist that the entire agreement is put into a formal, written document. This new agreement should clearly outline every detail you’ve negotiated, from the exact severance pay amount to the end date for your health insurance coverage. Read this document carefully before you sign it. Make sure all the agreed-upon terms are written down and that nothing has been omitted or changed. If you’re unsure about any of the legal language, especially clauses that release the company from future claims, it’s wise to have an attorney from a dedicated firm review it with you.
Prepare for Any Outcome
While negotiating often leads to a better outcome, it’s important to be aware of the potential risks. In rare cases, an employer might rescind the severance offer entirely after a counteroffer, though this is uncommon if your request is professional and reasonable. The more likely risk is that they simply say no, leaving you with the original offer. However, it’s important to weigh this against the potential reward—you could secure thousands of dollars more in pay or benefits.
It’s crucial to note that this advice applies to standard severance negotiations. If you believe you are the victim of retaliation at work or that your termination was illegal—for instance, if it was based on discrimination or happened after you reported illegal activity—your situation is different. In these cases of potential wrongful termination, you should speak with an employment lawyer immediately.
Related Articles
Frequently Asked Questions
Will my employer take back the offer if I try to negotiate? This is a common fear, but it’s very rare for a company to withdraw a severance offer just because you tried to negotiate. As long as your counteroffer is professional and reasonable, the worst they will likely do is say no. Companies offer severance packages to protect themselves from future legal claims and ensure a smooth exit. They have a strong incentive to finalize the agreement, so approaching the conversation as a standard business negotiation is usually a safe and smart move.
How much time do I have to review a severance agreement? You should never feel pressured to sign on the spot. While the exact deadline can vary, federal law gives employees over the age of 40 at least 21 days to consider an agreement that waives age discrimination claims. This is a good benchmark for anyone. Take the time you need to read the document carefully, understand every clause, and consider seeking legal advice before signing away your rights.
Can I still collect unemployment benefits if I get severance pay? Yes, in California, receiving a severance package typically does not prevent you from collecting unemployment benefits. However, the structure of your payment can affect the timing. For example, if your severance is paid as a lump sum, it usually won’t delay your benefits. If it’s paid out over time like a regular paycheck, it might. It’s always a good idea to check with California’s Employment Development Department (EDD) for guidance specific to your situation.
What should I do if my employer refuses to negotiate? If your employer holds firm on their initial offer, you have a decision to make. You can either accept the original terms or decline the package. If you choose to decline, you retain your right to pursue legal action against the company. This is a critical moment to assess your situation. If you believe your termination was unlawful, you should speak with an employment lawyer to understand the strength of your potential claims before making a final choice.
Is severance pay considered taxable income? Yes, it is. The IRS views severance pay as supplemental wages, which means it is subject to the same federal and state income taxes as your regular salary. Social Security and Medicare taxes will also be withheld. When you calculate the value of your offer, be sure to account for these deductions to get a realistic idea of the net amount you will actually receive.